Cold storage is increasingly on ice in the alternative assets basket, while self-storage continues to feel the warmth of investor interest. Recent commentaries from the credit rating agency, Morningstar DBRS, chart divergent outlooks for the two property types, but still identify opportunities for savvy operators.
Both asset classes have experienced slippage from robust pandemic-era results earlier this decade. However, that’s been most profound for cold storage, which now wrestles with a supply glut, weakened demand and rising costs in a sector that has always been more operationally intensive than other types of warehouse space. As well, cold storage has conventionally been weighted toward pricier and/or discretionary food and beverage categories that have been losing market share in more tenuous economic times.
“Rather than maintaining the elevated inventory levels accumulated amid the supply chain disruptions of 2022, food manufacturers and retailers have increasingly optimized their supply chains and working capital,” Morningstar DBRS analysts observe. “This has resulted in lower inventory requirements and faster inventory turns, reducing average pallet positions and storage duration across the cold storage network.”
Throughput volume, which measures the quantity of product moving through the warehouse system, has dropped from peak levels in 2022 when vaccines were also a more prominent occupier of space. In contrast, refrigerated warehouse capacity in the United States grew by roughly 14.5 per cent in the period from 2021 to 2025.
The U.S. national vacancy rate rose to 7.7 per cent in the second quarter of 2026, representing an 80 basis point (bps) increase from Q4 2024 and a 330-bps leap from Q1 2024. The cold storage sector registered 15 million cubic feet of negative absorption over the course of springtime, as 56 million cubic feet were vacated against 41 million cubic feet of uptake.
Vacancy is predominantly concentrated in older assets, while facilities coming onto the market since 2020 are capturing new leasing. Analysts typify the latter for its “greater clear heights, stronger power capabilities, automation, and greater operating efficiency” and hypothesize that it’s also relatively free of near-term competition from new speculative development.
Given that cold storage construction costs are now pegged in the range of USD $130 to $350 per square foot (psf), while costs for conventional warehouse space are in the range of USD $85 to $150 psf, activity is projected to be largely restricted to build-to-suit, pre-leased ventures. Rebalancing of supply and demand is expected to come eventually with continued removal of older, obsolescent facilities from the market.
For now, Morningstar DBRS analysts reiterate that larger, well-capitalized operators are better insulated and generally have more flexibility to shift with market demand. That’s demonstrated in: expansion beyond core food products into markets such as pharmaceuticals and pet food storage; continued investment in automation, energy efficiency and other technological upgrades; and culling of obsolescent stock.
“Although earnings growth may remain muted until utilization meaningfully improves, we expect stronger operators to emerge from the cycle with more efficient portfolios and improved competitive positioning,” analysts conclude. “More broadly, the downturn could accelerate consolidation within the fragmented temperature-controlled warehouse sector as well-capitalized operators selectively pursue assets or portfolios from smaller or more highly leveraged competitors.”
Meanwhile, self-storage is deemed to be one of North America’s “most resilient and stable” commercial real estate sectors for its steady occupancy, strong cash flow and low operating costs. Rent growth has subsided from the peaks seen in the period from 2020 to 2022, but so, too, has a spurt of new supply that arose from those heady days.
Market demographics, such as household mobility, in-migration, housing profile and affordability, influence demand. “Performance is increasingly differentiated by market and asset quality, with climate-controlled, smaller unit storage, supply-constrained markets, and higher-quality Class A storage facilities able to support stronger pricing,” the analysis states.
Looking specifically at self-storage real estate investment trusts (REITs), Morningstar DBRS highlights their ability to mitigate current higher financing costs and elevated cap rates, and their success in generating ancillary revenues from management fees, client insurance fees, portable storage unit rentals and parking for boats, recreation vehicles and other vehicles. There is also opportunity for institutional players to move in further.
“In the U.S., the 100 largest operators manage approximately 60 per cent of net rentable area and, in Canada, ownership is even more fragmented, providing larger institutional owners and operators with opportunities to acquire smaller portfolios and individual mom-and-pop operators,” analysts note. “In major Canadian markets, higher-quality assets continue to attract institutional demand, as reflected in SmartStop’s growth in Toronto, Montréal and Vancouver.”



